Self-esteem and self-efficacy - how to organise a psychology thesis chapter

In your draft chapter, self-esteem means your attitude towards yourself in one place and confidence that you can complete a task a few pages later. Your supervisor comments: “Please distinguish the concepts.” You already have the literature and questionnaire descriptions, so you add a definition. Yet the problem returns in the hypothesis and conclusion. The text may be changing what it describes, even though the terms still sound similar.

Published: About 28 minutes to read
Polish guide cover: Self-esteem or self-efficacy? Separate the concepts, check the measures and revise the paragraph.

In your draft chapter, self-esteem means your attitude towards yourself in one place and confidence that you can complete a task a few pages later. Your supervisor comments: “Please distinguish the concepts.” You already have the literature and questionnaire descriptions, so you add a definition. Yet the problem returns in the hypothesis and conclusion. The text may be changing what it describes, even though the terms still sound similar.

Start organising the chapter by separating three kinds of information: an overall evaluation of oneself, a generalised belief in being able to cope with difficulties, and a belief about completing a particular task. Record actual task performance separately. Mark which kind of information each paragraph addresses. Only then revise the terminology, select sources and check whether your research question matches the instrument used.

In a thesis in Psychology, this approach helps preserve the meaning of your argument during editing. Below, you will work through a complete example: from a passage that confuses the concepts, through defining the scope and reading publications, to a revised passage and decisions about the rest of the thesis. You do not need completed findings from your own study. You need a draft chapter, a statement of its aim and the sources you actually use.

Why does swapping two terms fail to fix the chapter?

If a sentence concerns an evaluation of self-worth, inserting the term “self-efficacy” will not correct it. That would change what the sentence says about the person. A similar problem arises when “competence” refers to a skill, a belief about that skill and the outcome of an action within the same text. These kinds of information can be considered together, but should not be treated as equivalent without explanation.

The concept of a construct is useful when editing. A construct is a phenomenon described theoretically that you want to understand or study. Its label alone does not establish its scope. When a source discusses self-esteem, read the definition and description of its measurement. Use those to decide whether it fits your paragraph. Two articles may use a similar Polish term while addressing different aspects of a phenomenon.

Read this draft sentence: “The student has high self-esteem because they received a good mark for their presentation.” It is unclear whether the author is describing the student's response to a question about themselves, a belief before presenting or simply the mark awarded by the lecturer. Before revising it, find the source of the information. If you only have the presentation mark, write about that mark. Do not add a psychological state that was not measured.

Leave brief comments about meaning beside passages you revise: “attitude towards oneself”, “general belief”, “task-specific belief”, “performance outcome”. These are working labels to remove from the submitted version. They help you notice when a paragraph begins with one issue and ends with another. Punctuation and repetition can be addressed later, once you know what you actually want to say.

Self-esteem and self-efficacy beliefs answer different questions

A brief guide to reading is this: global self-esteem concerns an overall attitude towards oneself, while self-efficacy concerns beliefs about one's capacity to act. This is a working explanation, not an item from a questionnaire. Bandura explicitly distinguishes judgements of self-worth from judgements about being able to perform an action. His chapter on constructing scales also stresses the need to specify the domain to which efficacy beliefs relate (Bandura, 2006, pp. 307-310).

When reading, ask: “Is the author describing how a person evaluates themselves, or what they believe they can do?” Then ask: “How broad is the activity concerned?” A belief in coping with a range of problems does not yet provide a precise account of a belief about preparing one particular presentation. Preserve that distinction in your chapter, rather than using the broad term for every case.

An original example can make the problem clear without pretending to be a measurement. Someone might describe themselves kindly yet feel unprepared to carry out an unfamiliar data analysis. They might also believe they can complete a familiar task while evaluating themselves critically more generally. These are possible illustrative situations. They are not research findings or grounds for assigning people a particular psychological profile.

Do not turn these distinctions into a simple division between “emotion” and “reason”. That shortcut could obscure the definitions you have adopted. What matters more in your chapter is how the sources define the object of evaluation and how the information was obtained. Adopt one clearly identified approach, and introduce others where their differences are relevant to the argument. Do not add more theories simply to lengthen the list of definitions.

Four kinds of information to keep distinct
Global self-esteem

Overall attitude towards oneself

The scope addressed by Rosenberg's SES.

General self-efficacy

Beliefs about coping with difficulties

The scope measured by GSES, without specifying one particular presentation.

Task-specific self-efficacy

A belief about a particular action

Requires an appropriate measure for the specified task and conditions.

Performance outcome

What was completed and evaluated

For example, a presentation mark. It does not replace a measure of beliefs.

This is a guide to editing, not a psychological test. First establish which information you have, then write the sentence.

What do SES and GSES mean in your chapter?

SES and GSES are easy to confuse when reading notes quickly. Similar abbreviations do not mean the instruments are the same. At the first mention, give the full name used in the source, the authorship and the relevant adaptation. Then use the agreed abbreviation consistently. If an English-language publication uses RSES, explain that name rather than leaving readers to think a third, unexplained instrument has appeared.

The publisher's description of the Polish SES presents it as an instrument for assessing general self-esteem. It names Morris Rosenberg as its author and Irena Dzwonkowska, Kinga Lachowicz-Tabaczek and Mariola Łaguna as the authors of the adaptation and the 2008 manual. This provides a sufficient basis for distinguishing the scope of SES from efficacy beliefs. It does not establish that an SES score describes preparation for a particular task (Pracownia Testów Psychologicznych PTP, n.d.).

GSES is the General Self-Efficacy Scale, called Skala Uogólnionej Własnej Skuteczności in Polish. Juczyński discusses Schwarzer and Jerusalem's instrument as addressing general beliefs about coping with difficulties and obstacles. In the same text, he distinguishes general measurement from measurement relating to specific situations (Juczyński, 2000, pp. 14-15). You should therefore not hide a question about a particular activity under the broad label of a GSES score.

For a theoretical chapter, do not reproduce questionnaire forms, scoring keys or norm tables. Explain why the instrument's scope matters to the study you are discussing. If you are describing your own methodology, use the documentation for the version actually administered. Check the rules for using, scoring and interpreting it with your supervisor. An instrument's description in someone else's article does not replace the documentation needed for your own study.

How do you define the chapter's scope when you already have a thesis topic?

Start with a sentence describing the aim without promising a result. For example: “This chapter clarifies the concepts needed to examine the relationship between global self-esteem and general self-efficacy among students.” This proposes a scope. If your question involves public speaking, name that separately and establish whether you mean beliefs before speaking, the performance itself or its evaluation. Do not automatically include all these issues.

Place the title, aim, questions and instrument descriptions side by side. If the title mentions “academic efficacy” but the methodology contains only GSES, flag the issue for clarification. Do not decide from the title alone that the entire study is inappropriate. First establish what the thesis author meant by that term and what was actually planned. Sometimes the scope needs a more precise description; sometimes the study design needs to change.

For a literature-based thesis, the scope may end with clarifying how the two concepts are defined and studied. For an empirical thesis, the chapter should also prepare the reader for the actual question and measurement. Do not end the theoretical chapter by promising a study that does not appear later. It is difficult to resolve that inconsistency by changing terminology alone.

Also record what the chapter does not cover. If you are not analysing appearance-related self-esteem, leave it outside the main argument. If you are not measuring presentation skills, do not build the whole argument around presentation performance. A brief statement of boundaries can help explain your literature selection. It does not need to become a separate catalogue of every possible topic in psychology.

What plan will connect definitions to your research question?

Do not begin with sections named after successive authors. First establish the questions the text should answer. The reader should understand why you move from definitions to measurement and from measurement to comparing studies. Organising around problems lets you discuss different publications together where they genuinely address a shared issue.

A working chapter plan about the two constructs might look like this:

  • global self-esteem: the definition adopted and its boundaries;
  • self-efficacy: its general scope and its relation to a task;
  • measurement approaches relevant to the publications discussed;
  • what research says about the relationship between the variables;
  • differences between studies and limitations of comparison;
  • a conclusion leading to your own research question.

Beside each part, complete the sentence: “After this passage, the reader will know…” For the section on instruments, this might be: “They will know why SES does not measure task-specific self-efficacy.” The research section needs an actual comparison, rather than another repetition of definitions. If two parts have the same purpose, check whether you are describing the same problem twice.

Before deciding section lengths, assign publications to them. If all you have on the relationship between the two variables is a general theoretical discussion, record that gap. Do not compensate by expanding the history of self-esteem research across psychology. Find a source that actually studies the relationship you need, or narrow the review question. The chapter's proportions should reflect its problem and the available literature, rather than the length of the first book you found.

How do you search for literature that addresses a specific gap?

Separate your search into definitions, instrument documentation and empirical studies. A theoretical text can help explain the conceptual distinction. To describe SES, you need a publication about that scale and its relevant adaptation. A statement about the relationship between two variables needs a study that actually included both. One relevant source does not automatically replace all three kinds of material.

Instead of searching only for “samoocena praca magisterska”, use combinations that match the gap in your text: “samoocena globalna poczucie własnej skuteczności”, “Skala Samooceny SES polska adaptacja”, “uogólnione poczucie własnej skuteczności studenci”. For English-language literature, useful terms include global self-esteem, general self-efficacy and the name of the relevant domain of action. Check definitions, however, rather than simply finding a word in a title.

Google Scholar and CEJSH can lead you to publications, but a record alone does not support every detail you might want to describe. Open the full document in a repository, on the journal's website or through its publisher. Check the authors, title, year, pages and publication type. If the full text is unavailable, record that limitation. Do not invent the method from the title or attribute interpretations from another article to the authors.

Once you find a study, check whether its participants resemble the group you are writing about. School pupils, students on different degree programmes and employed adults do not become one sample simply because they completed a questionnaire. A publication about another group may offer an important argument, but make its role clear. Write “a study of pedagogy students” if that was the sample, rather than shortening it to “a study of all students”.

What should you record after reading a study?

Keep its bibliographic details and the location of the particular finding. Then note, in your own words, the aim, participants, instruments, data collection method and finding needed in your chapter. Separate these from your comment: “this could help in the section on…” A few days later, you will be able to tell what came from the authors and what was your idea for using the publication.

For each construct, give the full name of the measure used. A note saying “confidence was studied” is insufficient. Also record whether the material involved self-reports, interview accounts, behavioural ratings or documented performance. This distinction will help you avoid writing about actual skill when the material contains only a person's statement. It is not a judgement of the whole study's quality, but information about what you can report from it.

Leave a separate space for limits on how the source can be used. “Global self-esteem was not measured” can matter more than another general comment about the importance of self-efficacy. It means the publication can help describe one construct or the context, but cannot establish a relationship between both. Similarly, the absence of a task-performance assessment prevents you from turning a participant's statement into information about their actual result.

Do not copy the whole note into the chapter in the order of its fields. The note helps you check the source. The paragraph should answer the reader's question. You might begin with a problem shared by several studies, then identify a difference in measurement and only then present their findings. When rearranging the material, retain who was studied and how the finding was obtained.

A reading example: what can you use from Rodek's study?

In a 2020 publication, Violetta Rodek described a purposively selected sample of 215 pedagogy students. She used GSES and an open-ended, partly structured interview. The interview stage included 24 people with low and 30 with high GSES scores. The author describes the study as diagnostic and descriptive, and notes the limits to generalisation arising from the sampling approach (Rodek, 2020, pp. 108-113).

Your note could therefore say: “an example of combining a general measure of efficacy beliefs with an exploration of students' independent learning”. Do not write “evidence of the effect of self-esteem on examination results”. The instrument identified is not SES, and the interview stage does not automatically become an experiment investigating the cause of behaviour. Notice, too, that the number interviewed and the size of the whole sample are different pieces of information.

The publication's role in your chapter depends on the question. In a methods section, it could show why a scale score should be distinguished from material describing learning experiences. In a section about students, it can provide context from a clearly identified degree programme. It should not replace a study of the relationship between global self-esteem and self-efficacy if that is the relationship you intend to discuss.

Check each publication this way: “What does this document allow me to say?” and “Which sentence in my chapter cannot be supported by it?” The second question protects against extending a conclusion too far. If a source does not fit the central argument, you do not have to remove it from your entire collection. You can use it as context or leave it in your notes, rather than force it into a paragraph where a different function is needed.

A complete editing example: from supervisor feedback to a revised passage

The following is an original, fictional example. The student “Marta” is drafting a thesis chapter on global self-esteem and general self-efficacy among students. She has not collected data yet. She has a thesis plan, several publications, descriptions of SES and GSES, and a comment from her supervisor: “Please separate the constructs and match the language to the planned measurement.” The example does not invent research findings or participants.

What text does “Marta” start with?

Her draft contains three sentences: “Self-esteem is faith in one's abilities, meaning a belief in successfully completing a task. For this reason, people with high GSES scores have high self-worth and achieve better results at university. The thesis will examine how self-esteem affects the ability to prepare a presentation.” This is a deliberately flawed passage for an editing exercise, not a quotation from a research publication.

“Marta” could begin by smoothing the style, shortening the first sentence and adding a citation. The paragraph would then read more fluently while still confusing the scope of the concepts. Before language editing, she therefore identifies what each sentence contains. The first equates an overall self-evaluation with a belief about a task. The second moves from one questionnaire to a different construct and then to university attainment. The third promises a question different from the thesis's working aim.

Three issues therefore need to be resolved: what the thesis addresses, which measures are planned and where the claim about university results comes from. “Marta” does not revise them in a single move. In her comments file, she writes “definition”, “unsupported inference” and “inconsistent aim”. These notes allow a discussion of specific decisions, rather than a general statement that the whole chapter needs rewriting.

What scope does she choose, and why?

After comparing the topic, working aim and planned instruments, “Marta” chooses global self-esteem and general self-efficacy as the scope. The presentation was an example of an everyday task in her notes, rather than the subject of the planned measurement. She therefore removes the promise to study presentation skills. She does not claim that a GSES score alone will answer that more specific question.

If preparing a presentation had been the thesis's actual focus, a different decision would have been needed. “Marta” would then have to discuss the task, conditions and suitable measurement with her supervisor, including whether performance should also be assessed. Adding “academic” to the name GSES would not suffice. That would be a different research route. In this example, she does not choose it because it does not match the agreed scope.

Her revised working aim is: “To establish a basis for studying the relationship between global self-esteem and general self-efficacy in a specified group of students.” The group and study procedure still need to be defined before the methodology is approved. At this stage, the sentence organises the chapter rather than pretending that the study design is complete.

How does she use the sources without inventing missing information?

“Marta” assigns different roles to the publications. She selects the relevant passage from Bandura to distinguish the concepts. She uses Juczyński's discussion to explain general measurement. She checks the publisher's documentation for SES. She retains Rodek's study as an example of the learning context and a different way of gathering material. None of these roles amounts to a ready-made finding about the relationship between the two variables in her future respondents.

She addresses the claim about better university results separately. The material presented contains no source supporting a claim that broad. “Marta” therefore removes the sentence from the paragraph and records a question for further searching in her notes. She does not replace it with “probably”, because adding a cautious adverb would not supply the missing evidence. If she later finds a suitable study, she will describe its specific scope.

What does the revised passage look like?

The passage below is an original proposal based on those decisions. It is neither a quotation from the publications mentioned nor a ready-made account of the student's own research:

Global self-esteem and self-efficacy should be treated as distinct constructs in this thesis. The first concerns an overall attitude towards oneself, while the second concerns beliefs about one's capacity to act. Bandura distinguishes judgements of self-worth from judgements about being able to perform an action (2006, p. 309). Adopting this distinction avoids using a description of one construct as a definition of the other.

The remainder of the chapter will focus on general self-efficacy. This scope corresponds to general beliefs about coping with difficulties, discussed by Juczyński in relation to GSES (2000, pp. 14-15). It is not equivalent to a belief about preparing one particular presentation. References to academic tasks serve an illustrative purpose here and do not mean that each task will be measured separately.

Distinguishing the concepts also guides the formulation of the research question. The planned study will address the relationship between global self-esteem and general self-efficacy. Asking this question does not predetermine the direction or strength of the relationship. Nor does it provide grounds for concluding that one variable causes changes in the other or that a questionnaire score replaces an assessment of academic skills.

What exactly did the editing change?

The first revision separated the two concepts. The second specified the level of generality of self-efficacy. The third removed the unsupported inference about academic attainment. The fourth aligned the end of the passage with the actual working aim. After these changes, “Marta” can revise the syntax and citations because she knows what each paragraph should convey.

Before sending the passage, “Marta” compares it with the rest of the document again. If the subsection is still called “The effect of self-esteem on presentations”, she must revise it or discuss the scope again. If “skill” remains in the hypotheses, she needs to check whether it matches the actual measurement. Successfully editing one paragraph starts the process of organising the thesis; it does not prove that every passage is now consistent.

What if your question concerns a specific task but you have GSES?

First establish whether you are before or after data collection. Before the study, you can clarify the scope of the question and measurement choice with your supervisor. After collecting the material, your first responsibility is to describe honestly what was actually measured. Do not quietly rename a score to match a more appealing thesis title. The reader should be able to trace the path from participants' responses to the conclusion.

Suppose the working aim says “a belief in being able to prepare a presentation independently”, but GSES is the only planned measure. Record the mismatch plainly: “The question is narrower than the instrument's scope.” This is a starting point for a decision, rather than a verdict on the whole thesis. Should the aim concern general beliefs, with the presentation serving only as context? Or is this particular task the focus, requiring an appropriate measurement plan? Do not combine those two routes without explanation.

If you retain the general question, check the consequences throughout the document. The subsection title, rationale for the aim and hypothesis wording should no longer promise a separate study of presentation efficacy. The presentation example can remain if it is clearly illustrative. Do not later describe it as a task completed by respondents if they did not actually perform it.

If you choose the specific question, do not independently add words to an established questionnaire's items and call the resulting version unchanged GSES. You need a rationale, an appropriate instrument or a planned procedure for developing one, and a check of the conditions of use. These are methodological decisions to discuss before the study. Editing can identify inconsistency, but cannot replace measurement documentation.

After data collection, prepare an account of the mismatch for discussion with your supervisor: the original question, the instrument version actually used, the information collected and the possible scope of the conclusions. Narrowing a conclusion does not make the material worthless. It allows you to use what it actually contains. If the project needs changing or more material is required, agree and document that rather than hiding it in a revised sentence.

How do you write a question and hypothesis without jumping to causation?

“Is global self-esteem associated with general self-efficacy?” is not the same question as “Does raising self-esteem cause self-efficacy to increase?” The first concerns an association. The second requires establishing the effect of a change. If you plan to collect two questionnaire scores in one study, do not automatically promise an answer to the second question. The presence of two variables alone does not describe a mechanism.

In a working hypothesis, name both constructs and the group in line with the plan. If you hypothesise a positive association, show which findings or arguments support its direction. Do not choose it merely because it sounds intuitive. If you are still looking for that basis, record a research question and extend the review. “A positive relationship should be expected” also needs justification if it forms part of an academic argument.

One useful wording pattern to adapt is: “A relationship is hypothesised between [first construct] and [second construct] in [specified group].” The brackets mark places to complete using your own project. This is not a ready-made hypothesis for every thesis, and it does not determine the analysis to use. The final wording should match the theory, measurement approach and planned way of testing the hypothesis.

Imagine material in which both responses were collected at one meeting and no planned intervention took place. A causal statement would leave unanswered what changed first and which alternative explanations were considered. Do not fill those gaps with an imagined sequence. State that you intend to assess an association in specified material and that a causal question lies outside that scope.

The same caution applies to “effect” in a subsection title. If the section only reviews scores occurring together, check whether the title promises more than the text provides. You could write “The relationship between global self-esteem and self-efficacy” if that is what you actually discuss. Where a source offers a stronger interpretation, distinguish the author's position from what your own study can establish.

Can you compare studies that use different measures of self-efficacy?

You can consider them together, but first establish the purpose of the comparison. Not every comparison needs to end with “the findings are the same”. Sometimes the most useful observation is a difference in scope: one publication concerns general beliefs, while another addresses beliefs about a specific action. Explain that difference rather than obscuring it under the shared label “confidence”.

Prepare a note with four questions: what was defined, what was measured, who was studied and under what conditions? Add a fifth: what conclusion does your paragraph need? If you are examining why measurement scope matters, different instruments may be an important part of the argument. If you want to say that another study reproduced exactly the same finding, check whether the same term really refers to a comparable measure and question.

Imagine two working descriptions created solely to practise selecting literature. The first concerns general beliefs about coping with difficulties. The second concerns beliefs about being able to deliver a presentation to a particular audience. Even without results, the difference in generality is clear. You can explain that difference in your chapter. You cannot add that one publication “confirms the other” without checking which question and finding are supposedly being confirmed.

Handle differences between groups in the same way. A study of students on one programme does not automatically become a study of everyone at university. If you use it as context, identify the programme and important sampling conditions. If you want to apply a finding to your own group, show the basis and limits of that comparison. Studying in Poland does not itself remove differences between participants, tasks and data collection methods.

End a comparative paragraph by answering its question, rather than listing authors. For example: “When comparing these publications, the distinction between general and task-specific measurement needs to be retained; the remainder of the review will focus mainly on the former.” This is your decision about the chapter's construction. It should follow from reading the publications identified and fit the thesis's scope, rather than act as a generic conclusion to any group of studies.

How do you revise a paragraph when one citation appears to support too much?

Check each sentence separately. A citation at the end of a long paragraph may suggest that the source's author made every statement before it. In this topic, it is particularly easy to combine a definition, an instrument description, a relationship with another construct and a causal conclusion in one sequence. Mark these four functions and compare them with the publication. Some may be supported; others may need another source or removal.

If a sentence explains the scope of GSES, place the reference beside that information. If the next sentence concerns your choice of chapter structure, make clear that it follows from the thesis's adopted scope. Do not attribute your subsection titles to the questionnaire's author. Your own reasoning is needed, but its boundary with the source you report must be clear.

When paraphrasing, change how an idea is presented while preserving its scope. Do not replace “belief” with “ability” to avoid repetition. Do not change “in the study group” to “in people” to shorten a sentence. Those changes alter the substance. If a term repeats because you are discussing the same construct throughout, precision can matter more than stylistic variety.

Separate your own examples from accounts of research findings. “This can be illustrated by preparing a presentation” gives the reader a clear signal. Do not add a fictional person's name to a real study as if that person had been a respondent. If an example contains invented statements, identify them as your own illustration. Otherwise, the reader may mistake them for empirical material absent from the source.

Should every similar word be replaced with one term?

No. Making terminology consistent should preserve the distinctions your thesis needs. “Self-esteem”, “self-report” and “performance assessment” can appear together because they serve different functions. Self-report describes how information is obtained from a person. It does not automatically name the construct of self-esteem. Performance assessment identifies what the result concerns. Removing those differences would simplify the text at the expense of meaning.

Establish the terms you use in your own argument, and note important differences when discussing a source. If an author uses a different Polish equivalent, explain it at the first relevant mention. You do not need to multiply alternative terms in brackets every time. The reader needs to know when the same construct has a different name and when the scope itself differs.

Do not interpret English self-esteem as any evaluation of a skill simply because ordinary Polish allows someone to say “oceniam swoje możliwości” (“I assess my abilities”). In academic writing, the definition and context establish meaning. Similarly, confidence may need explanation: the word “confidence” in a translation does not make a measure equivalent to GSES. If in doubt, return to the original term and the method description.

For work across the whole document, you can use the guide A working glossary and consistent terminology in your thesis. The key decision in this chapter is specific: record global self-esteem, general self-efficacy and task-specific beliefs separately. A glossary should help maintain those distinctions. It should not become a list of random synonyms for automatic replacement throughout the file.

How do you respond when your supervisor asks you to clarify the concepts?

Prepare a brief account of what you changed and where it can be checked. For example: “I separated the definitions of global self-esteem and self-efficacy. In the measurement section, I clarified the scope of GSES. I removed the unsupported sentence about university results and connected the conclusion to the question about the relationship between the two constructs.” This account should reflect changes you actually made.

If a decision is still needed, make it specific. Rather than asking “Is it right now?”, you might say: “Are we retaining general self-efficacy, or should the aim concern a belief about a particular task?” Attach the current aim and the planned measure's name. Your supervisor can then see what needs deciding, without reconstructing the whole mismatch from scattered comments.

Keep the version from before the changes. This lets you compare the scope as well as the wording. If you revised a definition, you can check whether you accidentally removed an important distinction or citation. If you changed the aim by agreement, it will be easier to find the passages that need updating. Do not treat the old version as evidence of correctness, however. It records changes and allows you to return to a passage if needed.

When you receive another comment, check its reach. A request to clarify one sentence does not always authorise a change of construct, instrument or the whole study design. If a revision has that consequence, identify it before continuing. Otherwise, you may produce a linguistically consistent document describing a different study from the one actually planned or conducted.

Check the whole chapter before submission

First read the argument itself, without editing the bibliography at the same time. For each paragraph, establish what it should explain and how the next one connects. Then compare the claims with the publications. Finally, check titles, abbreviations, references and bibliographic entries. This sequence keeps your attention on meaning before small formatting differences take over.

Use these questions for the final review:

  • Is the meaning of self-esteem adopted in this thesis clear?
  • Do the general and task-specific levels remain distinct?
  • Are SES and GSES named correctly and assigned separate roles?
  • Are beliefs, behaviour and outcomes described with appropriate words?
  • Does each statement about a study match its method and participants?
  • Do the question, hypothesis and instrument descriptions concern the same constructs?
  • Has a causal statement appeared where you are establishing only an association?
  • Is your own example clearly separated from information in the publications?
  • Does the conclusion lead to the actual aim of the thesis's next part?

Also check in the opposite direction: from the research question back to the theoretical foundations. Find the passage explaining each construct and the publications supporting the proposed relationship. If the question contains a term the chapter does not explain, you have a specific gap to address. If an extensive subsection does not help explain any decision, reconsider its purpose and proportions.

After this review, you should be able to explain in a few sentences what you are writing about, where the concepts' meanings come from, what the adopted measurement can show and where your conclusion ends. In “Marta's” example, the revision removed unsupported jumps between those levels. You can do the same work on your own passage while preserving the agreed topic, actual material and your university's requirements.

Questions about the chapter, measures and editing

What should a research instrument description in a thesis include?

State the instrument’s name and origin, purpose, language version, structure, response options and scoring rules. Explain its conditions of use, checks performed and limitations. Describe the questionnaire actually used rather than a revised version created afterwards.

Must the first chapter of a thesis start with definitions?

There is no universal rule for this. You can start with a brief presentation of the problem and an explanation of the chapter's purpose, then clarify key concepts. Select definitions according to the objective of the work and compare their significance for the issue being analysed. The order depends on the discipline, the nature of the work, and the supervisor's guidelines.

Does every paragraph in a theoretical chapter require a footnote?

It is not the number of paragraphs that decides, but the origin of the information. Others' findings, definitions, data, arguments, and paraphrases require source attribution according to the applied style. Your own introduction to the chapter structure may not require a citation. However, the reader must know which sentences are based on a specific publication. One footnote at the end of a long paragraph may be insufficient when discussing multiple authors.

What to do if the hypothesis could not be tested?

Write what prevented its evaluation: lack of necessary measurement, incomplete data, or other limitations. Distinguish the inability to evaluate from a result that does not support the hypothesis. Agree on the next steps with the supervisor, without adding answers or changing the data.

What should I send if I already have feedback from my supervisor?

Send the current version of the thesis, the supervisor's comments, guidelines, and the deadline. If the comments concern a specific chapter or results, highlight those sections. Based on this, I will define the scope of changes, the price, and the possible completion date.

How do I get a proofreading quote and delivery date?

Send your text, describe the changes you need and give your deadline. I will assess whether proofreading is enough or more extensive editing is needed, then discuss the price and what can be completed within your timeframe.

Sources

  • Juczyński, Z. (2000). Poczucie własnej skuteczności – teoria i pomiar. Acta Universitatis Lodziensis. Folia Psychologica, 4, 11-24. Scope used: the distinction between general and situational measurement and the description of GSES, pp. 14-15. Full text in the University of Łódź repository: https://repozytorium.uni.lodz.pl/xmlui/handle/11089/3433
  • Rodek, V. (2020). Poczucie własnej skuteczności jako czynnik różnicujący samodzielne uczenie się studentów. Studia Edukacyjne, 58, 107-122. DOI: 10.14746/se.2020.58.6. Scope used: the study's aim and character, participant selection, GSES and the interview stage, pp. 108-113. Full text: https://pressto.amu.edu.pl/index.php/se/article/download/26015/23741
  • Bandura, A. (2006). Guide for constructing self-efficacy scales. In: F. Pajares, T. Urdan (eds.), Self-Efficacy Beliefs of Adolescents (pp. 307-337). Information Age Publishing. Scope used: specifying the domain and distinguishing efficacy beliefs, self-esteem and expectations, pp. 307-311. Full text in a University of Texas at Arlington resource: https://bpb-us-e1.wpmucdn.com/websites.uta.edu/dist/1/4994/files/2021/07/Guide-for-Constructing-Self-Efficacy-Scales-Bandura2006.pdf
  • Pracownia Testów Psychologicznych Polskiego Towarzystwa Psychologicznego. (n.d.). SES. Skala Samooceny Rosenberga. Publisher's description: general self-esteem, the instrument's author and the authors of the adaptation and manual. Accessed: 20 November 2026. https://www.practest.com.pl/sklep/test/SES

Send your chapter for editing with a clearly defined scope

Attach your draft, thesis topic and aim, university guidelines, sources used and your supervisor's comments. If you already have a methodology, include a description of the instruments actually used. At StudentSupport, you can discuss proofreading and editing a completed chapter, including conceptual consistency, the structure of the argument and precise language. These materials will help establish the scope without guessing decisions that are still missing.

Bachelor’s and master’s thesis proofreading and editing
Describe which passages need revision and attach the material for discussion.

Related articles

Participatory budgeting turnout - how to compare two cities in a public administration thesis

You have two reports on participatory budgeting. One gives the number of “votes cast”, the other the number of “voters”, and your supervisor expects you to compare turnout. Start by checking who or what each report counted. Look for references to people, ballots and votes for projects in both documents, and write down the denominator behind each percentage. If you cannot establish the number of eligible voters on the same basis, you can calculate the number of people who cast a valid vote per 100 residents in each city. Label the measure accordingly. If you cannot establish the number of people in one city either, keep any total of votes for projects separate. In a thesis in the “” programme, you can show how to reconcile the documents and use them to write the methods, results and discussion. The example takes you through two fictional reports. The larger city received more ballots, and its participation figure per 100 residents was lower. You will also see what you can write when the voting rules or reporting prevent that calculation. All numbers for City A and City B are invented. The real publications illustrate how to verify definitions and explain limitations. In participatory budgeting, residents vote on how to allocate part of a municipality's spending. Article 5a of Poland's Act on Municipal Self-Government defines participatory budgeting as a special form of public consultation. It provides for a municipal council resolution setting rules for voting, determining results and making them public. To compare two editions in a thesis, find the resolution that applied to each edition and the document reporting its results. The Act gives the study its administrative context. The documents for each edition explain what the reported categories mean and how the figures were compiled. Start by choosing whether your question concerns participation by individuals, ballot validity or support for projects. You can cover all three in a thesis, provided each has a defined unit and sources. The main question here is “How many people cast a valid vote per 100 residents in the editions studied in the two cities?” A...

Read article

Sense of safety and incident counts - how to revise conclusions in an internal security thesis?

Your chapter contains two findings: fewer survey participants rate neighbourhood safety positively, while an institution's summary records fewer interventions. The conclusion reads: “Residents fail to recognise the improvement in safety”. That sentence goes beyond the findings. First, check whether you are comparing the same area, period, group and type of information. A resident's assessment and the number of entries in a register may describe different things and need not change in the same direction. Start the revision with three separate sentences: what participants said about the neighbourhood, how they rated the specified service and what the records actually counted. Only then explain what comparing this information can establish. Do not decide in advance that the survey is wrong or that the register proves an improvement. Both materials can be useful if you preserve their actual meaning. This guide concerns revising a completed chapter for the “” programme. We will work through a complete fictional example, from an inconsistent paragraph and three summaries to revised findings, a limitation and a recommendation. Your first task is to add an answer beside each number: “A count of what, concerning whom, where and when?”. This will identify a specific correction before you start polishing the style. In one chapter, “safety” may mean a feeling, in another an incident count, and in the conclusion an assessment of an institution's work. The reader may then assume that every section measures the same property. Establish the scope of each use. When a sentence says “safety is high”, ask whether it is based on a neighbourhood survey response, an assessment of a particular threat or a defined administrative indicator. Without that information, even a correctly calculated value remains unclear. Klamut's model of experiencing security distinguishes a sense of security from reflection on security. The first aspect concerns an experienced state, while the second concerns taking security into account when thinking about one's life situation. The instrument was examined with 949 adults, mainly students (Klamut, 2019). Use this distinction in your chapter as a reminder that similar labels need not mean the same thing. Do not describe your own...

Read article